Weblogic Joomla Template Demo

IS JUDGING BIASED FOR CARNIVAL FLOATS ?
 
ImageFor the fourth year running, Abbots Langley School was awarded first prize in the schools category for the Carnival floats. As a result, My Abbots has received letters and emails concerned that schools within the area will soon turn their back on entering a float if they continue to be overlooked.
One of the letters we received, which came from an M Gillingham, said: “When will the Carnival organisers realise that they are turning schools away from the biggest event in the village calendar by persistently handing Abbots Langley School 1st prize in the schools category? This is not about the winning, it’s about the taking part, and the evidence shows that such a one-sided approach is pushing schools away. Please, Committee and Council, think again.” My Abbots spoke to the President of the Watford Lions, Frances Turner, one of the judges for this year’s floats, who told us that there is certainly no axe to grind with any of the schools. She said: “MK Ginder have won the community award quite a few years in a row and nothing has been said about that. We judged the floats on how much effort had gone into them and whether they could be recycled, among other things. Myself and the two other judges, Council Chairman Ivy Young and Daniel Dark from Leavesden Studios, did not even confer this year and went round the floats on their own to judge them. I don’t even live in the area so I can honestly say there is no bias towards any of the schools.” A number of people came up to us at the carnival expressing their disappointment, but do you agree with them, or is this just all a little bit petty? Let us know your thoughts at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

Users' Comments  
 

Average user rating

 

Display 10 of 10 comments

1. 17-07-2008 16:31

I'm Angry...
:(  
This is the first float that I've been involved with. I can't comment on why ALS won on previous occasions. But I can say that the only input we parents had (apart from the backdrop artwork) was to put together the work produced by the children. From Nursery to Year 6, they used their half term homework to make the various strands of design. Planning started in March and I think the result of this preparation spoke for itself. As did the Judges! Hopefully this will dispel any rumours that parents did everything! Maybe ALS won't enter next year, but what value is the victory then? :roll
Abbots Mum

2. 17-07-2008 16:13

Get over it!!
Having read the article and comments posted on this site, I thought for a moment that I had been transported in my sleep to rural France or maybe California (during a very bad year). It is usually those regions responsible for the sourest grapes! I didn't see the floats so cannot comment on which was best. But I can take exception to the suggestion that voting was biased. Upstanding members of the community donated their time to judge the floats and to suggest anything underhand, is an attack on their characters. How must they feel now? In the words of the song, "Dry your eyes mate..." :cry
Desperate Dad!!

3. 16-07-2008 18:08

j,s
the parents at abbots langley school made a great effort for weeks before the carnival, organising the children in groups to do art work and painting partys they all worked really hard and enjoyed every minute so perhaps these moaning mums from other schools should take a leaf out of abbots book and just enjoy and stop being petty and spoiling the atmosphere for everyone
jeanette

4. 15-07-2008 16:24

Ms
Honestly, you parents are acting like children yourselves. There's nothing wrong with a little competition in order for you to improve. If it bothers you so much, put in the extra effort next year.
E Evans

5. 15-07-2008 12:40

...
Putting the childrens work onto Abbots Langleys school float was a family event enjoyed by everyone who participated. Alot of work went into to it. The other school floats were also fantastic. Sometimes we win, sometimes we loose thats part of life. We need to show our children a positive reaction to this!
Anon

6. 15-07-2008 06:27

Biased judging or best effort?
so M Gillingham thinks that the winning of the best school float should be shared out? when i was at school, i was taught that the more time, effort and thought you applied to a project resulted in better marks, unfortunatly today's parents seem to be teaching poor little johny that just by entering something you have a right to a prize.May be Abbots school have produced the best float and rather than moan or imply that the other schools wont enter next year they should double their efforts.Think how rewarding to win ,rather than having it handed to you because its your turn to win. :sigh
Kevin Brown

7. 12-07-2008 06:34

Carnival Floats
I'm still disgusted with Abbots Langleys School behaviour at last years carnival. Having won, the children and parents chanted in a very aggressive way how they were 'the best' for the whole of the route. I felt extemely uncomfortable witnessing this with parents and children from the other schools. Tanners Wood and Breakspeare School have floats which the children themselves have spent alot of time and effort in preparing. Whereas Abbots Langley School Float looks prepared by parents. No contest in my mind.
Susan

8. 11-07-2008 17:53

...
after reading the latest addition of the fantastic my abbots...once again there seems to be bad feeling between the two schools regarding ALS winning another year, i was impressed with just how much the whole school had got involved in decorating and making things for the float. I feel that this is more to do with the parents been upset rather than the children, as at the end of the day it is the taking part that counts, and both schools seemed to enjoy the day. This whole situation does seem petty and there doesn't need to be bad feeling between the schools after all we are a community. :?
louise

9. 10-07-2008 18:38

Carnival 08
I agree that Abbots Langley School put in alot of effort, however, Tanners Wood Float was also exceptional. I thought the van with funky music & lots of children that had learnt dances and looked fantastic in their year of the Dragon costumes, the atmosphere was fantastic as they passed through the village, once they had passed the atmosphere quickly dulled to a random clap let alone cheere , surly that has to speak volumes. There was alot of dissapointment in the crowd as the award yet again went to ALS. Maybe select different judges each year from local shops. Why the same people :?
Mrs Arnold

10. 10-07-2008 10:36

...
If you actually look at the effort that was put in by the children/parents then you will see why Abbots Langley school win every year. Yes i agree it is about taking part and encouraging , however it would also be disappointing for the children to see that the floats that put the least amount of work in could win. The judging is also based on different catagories, so unless you know what these are you cannot make comments that is it is biased.
John

Display 10 of 10 comments

Add your comment



mXcomment 1.0.7 © 2007-2008 - visualclinic.fr
License Creative Commons - Some rights reserved
< Prev   Next >
Joomla Templates by JoomlaShack